Socyberty > Gay & Lesbians

Policing Marriage: Gays and Lesbians

One reason commonly offered in defense as to why gays and lesbians should not be allowed to marry is "marriage is about having children". This looks into that reasoning.

A small number of people, but particularly those of some religions, feel they have the right to police who can get married, who cannot, and for what reason. Two of the groups often targeted against being allowed to marry are homosexuals and lesbians. One of the reasons often suggested as to why they should not be allowed to marry is that "Marriage is about having and raising children". I find this point to be particularly of interest and 100% laughable.

So often the argument is used, and I wonder do these people even think about what they are saying, or suggesting?

  1. Does this mean that people who are infertile can not get married?
  2. Does it mean that people who do not want children should not get married?
  3. Will they protest people past child bearing years getting married?
  4. Does being married mean you are a suitable person for raising kids?
  5. What if the person had children from a previous relationship?
  6. Should couples be forced to divorce when their children leave home?
  7. It infers ignorance that homosexuals cannot have children or do not want them.
  8. Should heterosexual people who are divorced and do not have custody of their children, be allowed to remarry?


They frequently reference the Bible when referring to this, which is odd because humans engaged in marriage type relationships long before the Bible was even put together, and marriage exists in many religions, not only those who follow the Bible.

Humans have lived in monogamous relationships for many generations, they held ceremonies to unite the couple even before it was called a "wedding". People united in bonds long before religion set a standard of rules, and to be fair, how is it acceptable for one religion to force its' belief system onto people who do not follow that religion?

Alas, I have wandered off topic. My real issue is the argument against allowing homosexuals to marry, because marriage is about having and raising children. I honestly feel that this is a lame excuse for a reason against homosexual marriages. I do not think many people even realize that by saying this they are insulting millions of other people. Not every marriage is about children, some marriages are actually about love and companionship.

Mostly, how does it hurt society on a whole if gays and lesbians are allowed to marry? The argument that this will result in a lower birthrate is laughable, people will have kids regardless of being married.

I would love to see somebody, anybody, who says "Marriage is for heterosexual couples only, because it's about raising children" speak up loudly against allowing marriage in older couples, or marriage in infertile couples. That person would have a whole lot more credibility than these ones who use it as an excuse to protest against allowing homosexuals to wed.

So before you catch your self uttering such total nonsense, ask yourself, what is the real reason you are against gays and lesbians being wed?

12
Liked It
I Like It!
Related Articles
How Legalizing Gay Marriage Can Benefit Society  |  Gay Marriage in Connecticut
More Articles by B Nelson
Is Racism Natural?  |  The N-word
Latest Articles in Gay & Lesbians
Judge Me Not  |  Same-Sex Right to Marry, or Commonly Known Now as Prop Eight
Comments (7)
#1 by Moses Ingram, Jul 28, 2008
Thank you for this article, and I agree with you completely. It is ridiculous to say that marriage is only about having children.
#2 by PR Mace, Jul 28, 2008
Great article with a good point. Do you know how many gay couples foster children that no one wants. They make great parents. As a straight friend of many gay friends, I am proud to be a part of the family. Thanks for you work.
#3 by nobert soloria bermosa, Aug 2, 2008
interesting article,well,same sex marriage are already allowed in some countries....good for them
#4 by B Nelson - author, Aug 2, 2008
to clarify, I am straight and married a second time, after my first husband passed away, I just think its ignorant the way some straight people try to police everybody else, when really the law does not affect them.
#5 by ts, Aug 19, 2008
God says it's wrong. That trumps any "argument" you could ever consider. God is beyond your logic.
#6 by smartie pants, Aug 19, 2008
We cannot say that "God" says it is wrong, we only know that the people who wrote the Bible said that "God" said it is wrong, and then too it depends which "version" of the Bible you follow, or if you follow your heart.

According to the Bible you are also suppose to kill people who wear different kinds of fabrics (eg. wool and cotton) at the same time! And should the laws then only apply to people who believe in God?
#7 by Denny Lyon, Sep 14, 2008
...my two cents worth: the hidden reality behind all the evangelical uproar is less about what they think God has said and really about how emotionally uncomfortable they are with a minority (about 1% of the USA population) that is not the same as them.

Which brings to mind the concept of spiritual development is about growing tolerance and understanding of those different from ourselves. Since it is God who knows the hearts of all of us, maybe we just ought to allow God to sort things out when we all get to Heaven, don't you think? I'm a big fan of erring on the side of love and wisdom as it is a life well lived, and, steeped in joy.
Post Your Comment:
Name:  
Copy the code into this box:  
Post comment with your Triond credentials?
Inside Socyberty

Activism

 /

Advice

 /

Crime

 /

Death

 /

Disabled

 /

Economics

 /

Education

 /

Ethnicity

 /

Folklore

 /

Future

 /

Gay & Lesbians

 /

Government

 /

History

 /

Holidays

 /

Issues

 /

Languages

 /

Law

 /

Lifestyle Choices

 /

Men

 /

Military

 /

Organizations

 /

Paranormal

 /

People

 /

Philanthropy

 /

Philosophy

 /

Politics

 /

Psychology

 /

Relationships

 /

Religion

 /

Sexuality

 /

Social Sciences

 /

Society

 /

Sociology

 /

Spirituality

 /

Subcultures

 /

Support Groups

 /

Work


Popular Tags
Popular Writers
Powered by
Socyberty
About Us
Terms of Use
Privacy Policy
Services
Submit an Article
Advertise with Us
Contact

© 2007 Copyright Stanza Ltd. All Rights Reserved.