Scienceray > Astronomy

Why Pluto is Not a Planet

Since its discovery in 1930 by an American amateur astronomer named Clyde Tombaugh, Pluto has been classified as the ninth planet of the solar system. Only to be removed from the solar planetary group in 2006. Why?

Since its discovery in 1930 by an American amateur astronomer named Clyde Tombaugh, Pluto has been classified as the ninth planet of the solar system. Only to be removed from the solar planetary group in 2006. Why? The following are the major criteria at classifying a heavenly body whether it's a planet or not:

  1. A planet must be in orbit around the sun.
  2. A planet must be massive to produce gravity strong enough to give it a round shape.
  3. A planet must dominate its orbit, that is, its path is in relative isolation.
  4. A planet should be by far larger than the rest of minor bodies in the solar system.
  5. A planet's orbit must be relatively located in the same plane as the other planets.

Planetary data has it that each planet in the solar system satisfies the above criteria while Pluto meets only the first and the second. It does not satisfies the third and fourth, for numerous other bodies populates its orbital vicinity and some of the members of these host of minor objects now known as the Kuiper belt are as large as Pluto itself - plutinos the astronomers would put it. Comparing to the rest of the planets, Plutos's orbit is relatively tilted away from the common orbital plane. Thus, neither the last is met.

The international community of astronomers convinced, Pluto was formally reclassified as one of the dwarf planets in 2006. The news quickly enkindled debate and controversy among various communities, even among astronomers. I think as far as science is concern there is nothing adverse to this remarkable scientific step. Had Clyde Tombaugh now alive, I believe he would have no opposition either.

Unfortunately, some visual teaching aids about the Solar System for graders here in the Philippines still maintains the nine planets I noticed, an intellectual act which I would certainly deify if I were in the shoes of those elementary school teachers.

14
Liked It
I Like It!
Related Articles
Pluto Report  |  The History of the Solar System
More Articles by Unofre Pili
Science and Religion: Did Einstein Believe in God?  |  Quantum Physics: Evidence of the Omnipresence of God
Latest Articles in Astronomy
A Handpicked Collection of Ultimate Space Pictures 3  |  Lunar Eclipse
Comments (13)
#1 by Rachel, May 27, 2008
Hmmm... I wonder what the school science book now says. Thanks for the warning, I will check with my son and find out how many planets they are being told in school now. :)
#2 by tracy sardelli, May 27, 2008
very interesting and informative article, thank you so much for sharing.
#3 by salvatore, May 27, 2008
great article, thanks for sharing.
#4 by deepbluesea, May 27, 2008
Very interesting article. I had heard this and checked my son's science book. It was older than 2006 so Pluto was still a planet, but he was taught in school that it isn't consider one anymore.
#5 by william rodriguez II, May 27, 2008
Nice article.Thanks for the info,bro.This is really informative.
#6 by nobert soloria bermosa, May 27, 2008
very informative,thanks for sharing buddy,
#7 by Josey, May 27, 2008
Great article. I grew up thinking there were 9 planets and didn't understand why Pluto was all of a sudden not considered a planet. Now I know! Thanks for the info.
#8 by Matt, May 29, 2008
Well i am still in School but seeing as i was told about planets years ago i know Pluto as a planet. Now howether i know it isn't
#9 by Lucy Lockett, May 31, 2008
That was sad, I liked thinking that there was a planet called Pluto! Oh well, now we know better and why, I guess I will have to adjust!lol
#10 by Shames, Jun 5, 2008
Very interesting article. Thanks for sharing.
#11 by TheMyth, Jul 26, 2008
hehe nice article... it was really absorbing...
#12 by Darlene McFarlane, Jul 27, 2008

Very nicely written. I remember when they removed Pluto from it's position but I didn't know why. Thank you for explaining it for me.
#13 by Unofre Pili, Aug 18, 2008
Thank you everyone. In case you like to read my other science-related articles feel free to visit

http://www.scienceray.com/writers/Unofre%20Pili.34346

Thanks.
Post Your Comment:
Name:  
Copy the code into this box:  
Inside Scienceray

Astronomy

 /

Biology

 /

Chemistry

 /

Earth Sciences

 /

Mathematics

 /

Philosophy of Science

 /

Physics

 /

Technology


Popular Tags
Popular Writers
Scienceray
About Us
Terms of Use
Privacy Policy
Services
Submit an Article
Advertise with Us
Contact

© 2007 Copyright Stanza Ltd. All Rights Reserved.